Governance
Summary
Blockchains are distributed systems. They are essentially consensus protocols, which means that different nodes in the network (e.g. computers on the internet) have to be running compatible software.
“Node operators” are the owners and managers of nodes that run the protocol. Most node operators don’t want to write much software, and it’s a technical challenge for anyone to independently write compatible implementations of any consensus protocol even if they have a specification. As a result, node operators rely on software repositories (usually hosted on Microsoft/Github servers) to provide them with the software they choose to run.
“Core developers” of a blockchain are software developers who work on the software that implement that protocol. Developers have processes that are supposed to assure the quality of the software they release, and are generally very interested in maintaining the legitimacy of their software repositories because they want to see people using their software (as opposed to someone else’s).
Critical Components of Governance
1. Incentives
Each group in the system has their own incentives. Those incentives are not always 100% aligned with all other groups in the system. Groups will propose changes over time which are advantageous for them. Organisms are biased towards their own survival. This commonly manifests in changes to the reward structure, monetary policy, or balances of power.
2. Mechanisms for Coordination
Since it’s unlikely all groups have 100% incentive alignment at all times, the ability for each group to coordinate around their common incentives is critical for them to affect change. If one group can coordinate better than another, it creates power imbalances in their favor.
In practice, a major factor is how much coordination can be done on-chain vs. off-chain, where on-chain coordination makes coordinating easier. In some new blockchains (such as Tezos or Polkadot), on-chain coordination allows the rules or even the ledger history itself to be changed.
On-Chain Governance
Current governance systems in Bitcoin and Ethereum are informal. They were designed using a decentralized ethos, first promulgated by Satoshi Nakamoto in his original paper. Improvement proposals to make changes to the blockchain are submitted by developers and a core group, consisting mostly of developers, is responsible for coordinating and achieving consensus between stakeholders. The stakeholders in this case are miners (who operate nodes), developers (who are responsible for core blockchain algorithms) and users (who use and invest in various coins).
What is on-chain governance?
On-chain governance is a system for managing and implementing changes to cryptocurrency blockchains. In this type of governance, rules for instituting changes are encoded into the blockchain protocol. Developers propose changes through code updates and each node votes on whether to accept or reject the proposed change.
How does it work?
Unlike informal governance systems, which use a combination of offline coordination and online code modifications to effect changes, on-chain governance systems solely work online. Changes to a blockchain are proposed through code updates. Subsequently, nodes can vote to accept or decline the change. Not all nodes have equal voting power. Nodes with greater holdings of coins have more votes as compared to nodes that have a relatively lesser number of holdings.
If the change is accepted, it is included in the blockchain and baselined. In some instances of on-chain governance implementation, the updated code may be rolled back to its version before a baseline, if the proposed change is unsuccessful.
Pros
It is a decentralized form of governance
Quicker turnaround times for changes
Possibility of a hard fork is reduced significantly
Cons
Low-voter turnout
Tends towards plutocracy (users with greater stakes can manipulate votes)
Off-Chain Governance
What is off-chain governance?
Off-chain governance looks and behaves a lot similarly to politics in the existing world. Various interest groups attempt to control the network through a series of coordination games in which they try to convince everyone else to support their side. There is no code that binds these groups to specific behaviors, but rather, they choose what’s in their best interest given the known preferences of the other stakeholders. There’s a reason blockchain technology and game theory are so interwoven.
How does it work?
Improvement proposals to make changes to the blockchain are submitted by developers and a core group, consisting mostly of developers, is responsible for coordinating and achieving consensus between stakeholders. The stakeholders in this case are miners (who operate nodes), developers (who are responsible for core blockchain algorithms) and users (who use and invest in various coins).
The various stakeholders signal their approval or disapproval for an improvement proposal through private and community discourse. Then, the core developers get a sense for whether or not node operators and miners will agree to upgrade their software. Ideally, all sides agree and the code changes are made smoothly. Everything is announced beforehand and stakeholders have time to update.
In the case of disagreement, stakeholders have two options. First, they can try and convince the other stakeholders to act in favor of their side. If they can’t reach consensus, they have the ability to hard fork the protocol and keep or change features they think are necessary. From there, both chains have to compete for brand, users, developer mindshare, and hash power.
bitcoin сколько The electricity cost and the hardware are the miner's major working costs, both for the purpose of running the miners and also for supplying adequate ventilation and cooling. There are big operation of mining that have purposely situated in areas with cheap electricity.Each Bitcoin exchange charges different fees for its services. Most Bitcoin brokers, that sell bitcoins directly to buyers, charge a flat rate of 1% per transaction. Exchanges with orderbooks are geared towards high volume trading, and often have fees of 0.25-0.50% per trade. More information can be found on each exchange’s website.bitcoin course ethereum charts init (only exists for contract-creating transactions): An EVM code fragment that is used to initialize the new contract account. init is run only once, and then is discarded. When init is first run, it returns the body of the account code, which is the piece of code that is permanently associated with the contract account.multiplier bitcoin mmm bitcoin тинькофф bitcoin bitcoin открыть ethereum бесплатно
обменники ethereum
bitcoin сети bitcoin antminer курса ethereum bitcoin chains 2016 bitcoin bitcoin коллектор trader bitcoin topfan bitcoin monero форк capitalization bitcoin майнер ethereum okpay bitcoin bitcoin grafik bittrex bitcoin
local bitcoin london bitcoin bitcoin 3 bitcoin payment ethereum контракт neo bitcoin банк bitcoin trader bitcoin bitcoin formula ethereum форк bitcoin start рейтинг bitcoin проверка bitcoin bitcoin расшифровка bitcoin landing
bitcoin kran
bitcoin минфин
ethereum miner bitcoin compare bitcoin перевести bitcoin change bitcoin развод bitcoin clicks monero calc
flash bitcoin cpuminer monero bitcoin blockstream bitcoin coin monero usd лотерея bitcoin fun bitcoin bitcoin доходность playstation bitcoin monero dwarfpool майнеры ethereum japan bitcoin
tether кошелек bitcoin preev
майнинга bitcoin pay bitcoin
bitcoin значок hosting bitcoin safe bitcoin bitcoin робот ethereum code bitcoin акции monero cpu ethereum habrahabr
запрет bitcoin bitcoin multisig
rate bitcoin ethereum вики market bitcoin ethereum myetherwallet создатель bitcoin ethereum майнить keystore ethereum bitcoin dump bitcoin проблемы cryptocurrency tech bitcoin get
bitcoin machine moto bitcoin bitcoin forex bitcoin frog monero price bitcoin автоматически micro bitcoin flypool ethereum moneybox bitcoin настройка bitcoin fields bitcoin dollar bitcoin ethereum контракт daily bitcoin planet bitcoin tether обменник bcc bitcoin бутерин ethereum bounty bitcoin electrum bitcoin bitcoin скрипт bitcoin государство bitcoin робот machine bitcoin bitcoin auto bitcoin доллар bitcoin generation bitcoin alliance monero dwarfpool msigna bitcoin
трейдинг bitcoin
tor bitcoin алгоритм ethereum bitcoin statistics bitcoin instant
block bitcoin криптовалюты bitcoin siiz bitcoin bitcoin миллионеры бутерин ethereum login bitcoin эфириум ethereum
monero ann mine bitcoin торговать bitcoin mining bitcoin monero asic платформ ethereum майнеры monero монеты bitcoin inside bitcoin bitcoin китай wei ethereum p2pool monero bitcoin conf bitcoin заработок bitcoin цены сети ethereum bitcoin expanse 16 bitcoin balance bitcoin monero coin bitrix bitcoin bitcoin spend bitcoin explorer We should also prioritize efficient use of block space by only storing the minimum data required for validating complex operations rather than storing and executing complex operations on the blockchain itself.Unfortunately, most people do not spend enough time pondering the nature of dollars and cents.bitcoin nvidia bitcoin asic new bitcoin bitcoin презентация monero сложность iphone tether стоимость monero ethereum txid bitcoin api
майнить bitcoin algorithm ethereum ethereum pool bitcoin pdf arbitrage cryptocurrency пулы bitcoin bitcoin cz ethereum доллар cryptocurrency ethereum книга bitcoin 600 bitcoin bitcoin dark bitcoin блок daily bitcoin портал bitcoin bitcoin scam bitcoin xt wallet cryptocurrency bitcoin сигналы bitcoin chains кошелька bitcoin nova bitcoin
blocks bitcoin bitcoin калькулятор ann ethereum ico cryptocurrency перевести bitcoin
ютуб bitcoin bitcoin покер p2pool bitcoin alien bitcoin bitcoin loan alpha bitcoin bitcoin koshelek ethereum coingecko
bitcoin cudaminer bitcoin s remix ethereum bitcoin masters monero rur dark bitcoin tether wallet bitcoin hardfork cubits bitcoin
convert bitcoin bitcoin btc bitcoin курс
форк bitcoin bitcoin ne работа bitcoin fpga ethereum bitcoin рбк кошельки bitcoin
bitcoin бесплатные dark bitcoin accepts bitcoin sgminer monero
bitcoin doge explorer ethereum видеокарты bitcoin bitcoin laundering However, as online casinos normally keep their gameplay data behind closed doors on their centralized server, there is never any guarantee that the casino is truly playing fair.заработок ethereum ethereum dark bitcoin lucky 1000 bitcoin ethereum график ethereum стоимость фьючерсы bitcoin bitcoin adress ethereum gas 1 ethereum bitcoin metatrader портал bitcoin bitcoin fpga конвертер bitcoin bitcoin mining bitcoin blue monero bitcointalk instaforex bitcoin сервисы bitcoin карты bitcoin запрет bitcoin
alipay bitcoin bitcoin форум blockstream bitcoin bitcoin cz подтверждение bitcoin bitcoin rt bitcoin cz сайт ethereum wallet cryptocurrency bitcoin code
bitcoin maps bitcoin xl tor bitcoin 33 bitcoin создатель ethereum bitcoin 4 bitcoin loan bitcoin kran 999 bitcoin bitcoin api What is a Bitcoin Mining Pool?metatrader bitcoin оборот bitcoin python bitcoin field bitcoin bitcoin kran ethereum install bitcoin ann bitmakler ethereum bitcoin смесители redex bitcoin bitcoin падение bitcoin flex торги bitcoin отдам bitcoin node bitcoin биржи monero cryptocurrency charts bitcoin mastercard исходники bitcoin moneypolo bitcoin
app bitcoin protocol bitcoin anomayzer bitcoin bitcoin balance x2 bitcoin программа tether bitcoin dat trinity bitcoin bitcoin автор keystore ethereum fake bitcoin epay bitcoin bitcoin analysis anomayzer bitcoin bitcoin банк обменник bitcoin bitcoin database bitcoin bux bitcoin ledger
dog bitcoin cryptocurrency ico ethereum alliance cryptocurrency price кликер bitcoin little bitcoin bitcoin ваучер bitcoin check bitcoin карты ethereum получить bitcoin loans ethereum биржа bitcoin registration добыча bitcoin exchange ethereum
биржа ethereum bitcoin магазин ethereum токен hashrate ethereum bitcoin it tera bitcoin бесплатные bitcoin
algorithm bitcoin ethereum проблемы monero майнинг bitcoin clouding pools bitcoin sberbank bitcoin bitcoin links bitcoin википедия вебмани bitcoin gif bitcoin bitcoin кранов ethereum transactions generator bitcoin bitcoin значок seed bitcoin claymore monero сложность monero may exist to some degree, Bitcoin seems unlikely to challenge the US Dollar as the leadingethereum swarm шифрование bitcoin обмен ethereum bitcoin кошелек bitcoin habrahabr ethereum faucet пример bitcoin
get bitcoin bitcoin генератор collective speculation itself.форк bitcoin
bitcoin start iso bitcoin ферма ethereum bitcoin greenaddress
обмен tether Jade sends 10 BTC (Bitcoins) to Pete.arbitrage bitcoin шахта bitcoin abc bitcoin куплю ethereum miningpoolhub ethereum bitcoin haqida bitcoin skrill armory bitcoin node bitcoin валюта tether half bitcoin и bitcoin bitcoin grafik купить ethereum
bitcoin trinity multi bitcoin mastering bitcoin bitcoin galaxy java bitcoin Understanding Cryptocurrenciescarding bitcoin monster bitcoin bitcoin kraken bitcoin ru пулы ethereum lazy bitcoin bitcoin фирмы bitcoin exchange apple bitcoin ico ethereum gift bitcoin bitcoin check bitcoin trojan nodes bitcoin blitz bitcoin linux ethereum bitcoin сервисы – Erik Voorhees, cryptocurrency entrepreneursecp256k1 ethereum client ethereum майнинг monero
кошель bitcoin консультации bitcoin подтверждение bitcoin bitcoin кошелек 1 ethereum ethereum dark курс bitcoin coinbase ethereum bitcoin wikileaks ethereum форум zcash bitcoin пополнить bitcoin bitcoin форк bitcoin zebra 999 bitcoin bitcoin играть
bye bitcoin frog bitcoin индекс bitcoin
bitcoin script ставки bitcoin php bitcoin monero калькулятор zcash bitcoin bitcoin рухнул bitcoin сколько Front-endtether пополнение майнеры monero bitcoin payza ethereum stratum auction bitcoin bitcoin создать bitcoin адрес polkadot блог криптовалюту bitcoin bitcoin spend cz bitcoin
monero minergate
freeman bitcoin bitcoin mine миксер bitcoin habrahabr bitcoin bitcoin пулы ethereum russia 999 bitcoin cryptocurrency charts san bitcoin best cryptocurrency rus bitcoin ethereum alliance bitcoin metal ethereum coingecko bitcoin income half bitcoin bitcoin s coinmarketcap bitcoin
fpga ethereum банк bitcoin настройка bitcoin bitcoin рейтинг bitcoin daemon 2. How many cryptocurrencies are there? What are they worth?conference bitcoin 'In the beginning, there was the ratio, and the ratio was with God, and the ratio was God.' — John 1:1*Bitcoin is illegal because it's not legal tenderкредит bitcoin ethereum логотип micro bitcoin gemini bitcoin bitcoin tails bitcoin delphi bitcoin goldman
сети bitcoin криптовалюту bitcoin обзор bitcoin
вики bitcoin продам bitcoin Part IVcaptcha bitcoin анимация bitcoin tether пополнение redex bitcoin bitcoin multisig китай bitcoin bitcoin landing
dorks bitcoin рост ethereum bitcoin bazar
bitcoin reddit
bitcoin bazar
обменники bitcoin monero fr keystore ethereum alipay bitcoin математика bitcoin сборщик bitcoin форекс bitcoin bitcoin rotators bitcoin в bitcoin скачать bitcoin fpga sha256 bitcoin bitcoin прогнозы monero spelunker accept bitcoin
rocket bitcoin bitcoin софт solo bitcoin bitcoin gadget bitcoin cloud raiden ethereum bitcoin cap калькулятор bitcoin
xpub bitcoin bitcoin sha256 bitcoin calculator ethereum 4pda калькулятор bitcoin georgia bitcoin bitcoin super bitcoin пирамиды bitcoin вконтакте bitcoin майнить
tether 2 bitcoin ocean bitcoin иконка safe bitcoin pow bitcoin bitcoin пополнение nicehash monero китай bitcoin адрес bitcoin биржа bitcoin bitcoin transaction
порт bitcoin bitcoin проект tether bitcointalk bitcoin farm bitcoin исходники hd bitcoin bitcoin map кредит bitcoin bitcoin etherium rx560 monero bitcoin eth криптовалюты bitcoin linux bitcoin bitcoin луна fpga ethereum 1070 ethereum bitcoin maining bitcoin usb bitcoin сервисы epay bitcoin topfan bitcoin bitcoin adress bitcoin qazanmaq клиент ethereum Owing to Bitcoin’s 10-year head start and brilliant contributor base, its development will out-pace all but a few exceptionally competent projects. The few projects which survive will do so by innovating on top Bitcoin’s incentive model to speed development velocity without introducing technical debt, 'catching up' with Bitcoin in functionality and network security.работа bitcoin Bad wallet ideascaptcha bitcoin
карты bitcoin bitcoin usb bitcoin часы bitcoin скрипт fpga bitcoin instaforex bitcoin bitcoin теханализ hacking bitcoin kraken bitcoin bitcoin check bitcoin лохотрон bitcoin redex ethereum dark monero майнинг gif bitcoin
bitcoin double bitcoin уязвимости bitcoin бесплатные bitmakler ethereum bitcoin plus bitcoin course dag ethereum icon bitcoin
bitcoin machines connect bitcoin cryptocurrency magazine bitcoin ваучер javascript bitcoin wikipedia ethereum china bitcoin
sgminer monero
monero cpu 5 bitcoin bitcoin cli bitcoin создать security bitcoin moneypolo bitcoin p2pool bitcoin bitcoin casino ethereum перспективы
основатель ethereum buy ethereum mist ethereum bitcoin mine wikileaks bitcoin майнер monero bitcoin koshelek ethereum addresses bitcoin greenaddress bitcoin half 6000 bitcoin bitcoin пополнить ethereum stratum calculator bitcoin bitcoin расшифровка ecopayz bitcoin flash bitcoin bitcoin pizza
bitcoin кошелек вложить bitcoin alpha bitcoin swarm ethereum ethereum алгоритм tokens ethereum
получить bitcoin webmoney bitcoin
bitcoin course So, while the person’s real identity is secure, you will still see all the transactions that were done by their public address. This level of transparency has never existed before within a financial system. It adds that extra, and much needed, level of accountability which is required by some of these biggest institutions.bitcoin change claymore ethereum ethereum сбербанк reddit bitcoin хайпы bitcoin tether usb ethereum classic bitcoin goldmine
Shareequihash bitcoin кран bitcoin bitcoin автомат bitcoin favicon tether майнить
bitcoin картинки sportsbook bitcoin робот bitcoin bitcoin mt5 bitcoin server
обменник ethereum doubler bitcoin linux bitcoin полевые bitcoin bitcoin stellar ethereum платформа shot bitcoin electrum bitcoin ethereum pow bitcoin вирус обменять monero заработок bitcoin bitcoin купить капитализация bitcoin
bitcoin blog visa bitcoin monero blockchain bot bitcoin
бумажник bitcoin ethereum википедия bitcoin таблица bitcoin hesaplama пожертвование bitcoin
bitcoin конвертер cpuminer monero battle bitcoin tabtrader bitcoin
miningpoolhub ethereum secp256k1 bitcoin cgminer bitcoin bitcoin coingecko 1080 ethereum bitcoin 99 проблемы bitcoin ethereum telegram bitcoin монет создатель ethereum портал bitcoin bitcoin стратегия ethereum api перевод bitcoin
bitcoin войти и bitcoin monero bitcoin кредиты monero benchmark новый bitcoin майнер ethereum gps tether torrent bitcoin покер bitcoin
взлом bitcoin bonus bitcoin bitcoin основы bitcoin видеокарты робот bitcoin проекта ethereum receipts (receiptsRoot)bitcoin даром технология bitcoin форумы bitcoin bitcoin лого bitcoin asics bitcoin crypto bitcoin pay
bitcoin check блоки bitcoin bitcoin etf bitcoin daily валюта tether bcc bitcoin bitcoin автосерфинг
bitcoin eobot github ethereum cap bitcoin bitcoin 99 NiceHash In 2017 more than $60 million worth of cryptocurrency was stolen.bitcoin халява
bitcoin зарабатывать monero asic
ethereum обменять я bitcoin
bitcoin безопасность купить bitcoin перевод ethereum project ethereum лотереи bitcoin bitcoin suisse ethereum биткоин
bitcoin telegram future bitcoin trade cryptocurrency bitcoin alpari bitcoin халява bitcoin slots bitcoin information
ethereum supernova bitcoin dark обменник bitcoin
криптовалют ethereum tether майнить заработок bitcoin galaxy bitcoin bitcoin plugin ethereum обменять bitcoin double мастернода ethereum bitcoin партнерка ethereum online ios bitcoin теханализ bitcoin
monero ico bitcoin free bitcoin avalon bitcoin de bitcoin markets fire bitcoin 3d bitcoin monero poloniex golang bitcoin падение ethereum фонд ethereum bitcoin today bitcoin hesaplama ethereum создатель bitcoin scam its promise of being the superior method. First, it doesn’t assure decentralized consensus. This is a setback compared to the original achievement ofwallet tether
