Bit gold
A long time ago I hit upon the idea of bit gold. The problem, in a nutshell, is that our money currently depends on trust in a third party for its value. As many inflationary and hyperinflationary episodes during the 20th century demonstrated, this is not an ideal state of affairs. Similarly, private bank note issue, while it had various advantages as well as disadvantages, similarly depended on a trusted third party.
Precious metals and collectibles have an unforgeable scarcity due to the costliness of their creation. This once provided money the value of which was largely independent of any trusted third party. Precious metals have problems, however. It's too costly to assay metals repeatedly for common transactions. Thus a trusted third party (usually associated with a tax collector who accepted the coins as payment) was invoked to stamp a standard amount of the metal into a coin. Transporting large values of metal can be a rather insecure affair, as the British found when transporting gold across a U-boat infested Atlantic to Canada during World War I to support their gold standard. What's worse, you can't pay online with metal.
Thus, it would be very nice if there were a protocol whereby unforgeably costly bits could be created online with minimal dependence on trusted third parties, and then securely stored, transferred, and assayed with similar minimal trust. Bit gold.
My proposal for bit gold is based on computing a string of bits from a string of challenge bits, using functions called variously "client puzzle function," "proof of work function," or "secure benchmark function.". The resulting string of bits is the proof of work. Where a one-way function is prohibitively difficult to compute backwards, a secure benchmark function ideally comes with a specific cost, measured in compute cycles, to compute backwards.
Here are the main steps of the bit gold system that I envision:
(1) A public string of bits, the "challenge string," is created (see step 5).
(2) Alice on her computer generates the proof of work string from the challenge bits using a benchmark function.
(3) The proof of work is securely timestamped. This should work in a distributed fashion, with several different timestamp services so that no particular timestamp service need be substantially relied on.
(4) Alice adds the challenge string and the timestamped proof of work string to a distributed property title registryfor bit gold. Here, too, no single server is substantially relied on to properly operate the registry.
(5) The last-created string of bit gold provides the challenge bits for the next-created string.
(6) To verify that Alice is the owner of a particular string of bit gold, Bob checks the unforgeable chain of title in the bit gold title registry.
(7) To assay the value of a string of bit gold, Bob checks and verifies the challenge bits, the proof of work string, and the timestamp.
Note that Alice's control over her bit gold does not depend on her sole possession of the bits, but rather on her lead position in the unforgeable chain of title (chain of digital signatures) in the title registry.
All of this can be automated by software. The main limits to the security of the scheme are how well trust can be distributed in steps (3) and (4), and the problem of machine architecture which will be discussed below.
Hal Finney has implemented a variant of bit gold called RPOW (Reusable Proofs of Work). This relies on publishing the computer code for the "mint," which runs on a remote tamper-evident computer. The purchaser of of bit gold can then use remote attestation, which Finney calls the transparent server technique, to verify that a particular number of cycles were actually performed.
The main problem with all these schemes is that proof of work schemes depend on computer architecture, not just an abstract mathematics based on an abstract "compute cycle." (I wrote about this obscurely several years ago.) Thus, it might be possible to be a very low cost producer (by several orders of magnitude) and swamp the market with bit gold. However, since bit gold is timestamped, the time created as well as the mathematical difficulty of the work can be automatically proven. From this, it can usually be inferred what the cost of producing during that time period was.
Unlike fungible atoms of gold, but as with collector's items, a large supply during a given time period will drive down the value of those particular items. In this respect "bit gold" acts more like collector's items than like gold. However, the match between this ex post market and the auction determining the initial value might create a very substantial profit for the "bit gold miner" who invents and deploys an optimized computer architecture.
Thus, bit gold will not be fungible based on a simple function of, for example, the length of the string. Instead, to create fungible units dealers will have to combine different-valued pieces of bit gold into larger units of approximately equal value. This is analogous to what many commodity dealers do today to make commodity markets possible. Trust is still distributed because the estimated values of such bundles can be independently verified by many other parties in a largely or entirely automated fashion.
In summary, all money mankind has ever used has been insecure in one way or another. This insecurity has been manifested in a wide variety of ways, from counterfeiting to theft, but the most pernicious of which has probably been inflation. Bit gold may provide us with a money of unprecedented security from these dangers. The potential for initially hidden supply gluts due to hidden innovations in machine architecture is a potential flaw in bit gold, or at least an imperfection which the initial auctions and ex post exchanges of bit gold will have to address.
ethereum история gadget bitcoin best bitcoin bitcoin ico the ethereum форк bitcoin покупка ethereum бесплатный bitcoin bitcoin antminer краны monero casinos bitcoin bitcoin 4 обменник bitcoin network bitcoin monero nvidia monero client bitcoin gambling alpari bitcoin ethereum сбербанк bitcoin зарегистрироваться bitcoin captcha bitcoin зебра bitcoin generate ethereum eth ethereum mine cryptocurrency calendar bitcoin страна bitcoin сатоши сборщик bitcoin cgminer monero conference bitcoin by bitcoin
bitcoin стратегия
bitcoin казино bitcoin linux bitcoin bloomberg деньги bitcoin игра ethereum удвоить bitcoin bitcoin satoshi moneypolo bitcoin hd bitcoin monero кран microsoft ethereum новости monero all bitcoin monero стоимость ethereum addresses price bitcoin фото bitcoin
bitcoin capitalization
amazon bitcoin
bitcoin история bitcoin оборот ethereum игра client bitcoin monero ann bitcoin investing foto bitcoin github ethereum bitcoin торговля ethereum логотип donate bitcoin андроид bitcoin приложения bitcoin tether gps вклады bitcoin магазин bitcoin trade cryptocurrency банк bitcoin падение ethereum bitcoin media payoneer bitcoin xbt bitcoin клиент bitcoin little bitcoin
bitcoin презентация ethereum упал ethereum эфир bitcoin mastercard monero прогноз bitcoin аналоги accepts bitcoin bitcoin анализ auction bitcoin bitrix bitcoin
loco bitcoin майнинг tether
bitcoin sberbank ethereum core bitcoin direct ethereum wallet особенности ethereum adc bitcoin майн bitcoin ethereum network ethereum course bitcoin валюта
byzantium ethereum safe bitcoin blacktrail bitcoin ethereum сайт bitcoin oil ethereum хешрейт bitcoin simple торговать bitcoin инвестирование bitcoin bitcoin png bitcoin компьютер bitcoin visa bitcoin usb bitcoin aliexpress ethereum cpu
bitcoin linux bitcoin download bitcoin сервисы bitcoin обналичить coffee bitcoin electrum bitcoin loans bitcoin курсы bitcoin ethereum core ethereum обменять bitcoin vpn
стоимость monero space bitcoin play bitcoin взлом bitcoin ethereum продать bitcoin monero количество bitcoin вики bitcoin
security bitcoin decred cryptocurrency майнер bitcoin bitcoin ann ethereum кран bitcoin motherboard bitcoin block collector bitcoin swiss bitcoin usb bitcoin цена ethereum проекта ethereum china bitcoin
bitcoin explorer secp256k1 ethereum сборщик bitcoin казино ethereum bitcoin сложность bitcoin anonymous bitcoin биржи bitcoin расчет суть bitcoin bitcoin пополнить ethereum клиент bitcoin 1000 moon ethereum cryptocurrency gold jax bitcoin
bitcoin lucky bitcoin рубль bitcoin minecraft monero hardfork buy tether bitcoin fpga
tether обменник bitcoin greenaddress bitcoin game bitcoin кран кошель bitcoin polkadot stingray cryptocurrency gold monero github bitcoin tm bitcoin hardfork bitcoin site yota tether ethereum ротаторы цена ethereum bitcoin advcash mist ethereum bitcoin bestchange github ethereum bitcoin doge bitcoin prune kong bitcoin bitcoin surf bitcoin бот картинки bitcoin
bitcoin ваучер monero rur alpha bitcoin bitcoin официальный
bitcoin arbitrage bitcoin lucky value bitcoin tether транскрипция
dorks bitcoin maps bitcoin armory bitcoin
bitcoin вклады bitcoin analytics advcash bitcoin bitcoin cash токен bitcoin комиссия bitcoin autobot bitcoin курсы bitcoin bitcoin перевести сложность ethereum ethereum обвал bitcoin казино bitcoin code
bitcoin darkcoin ethereum cryptocurrency bitcoin cap bitcoin вложить cryptocurrency price майнинга bitcoin транзакции ethereum monero poloniex ethereum телеграмм bitcoin hype rush bitcoin bitcoin перспективы bitcoin обменники 999 bitcoin bitcoin мерчант ethereum цена bitcoin автомат ethereum курсы россия bitcoin
usa bitcoin ethereum картинки sportsbook bitcoin konvert bitcoin crococoin bitcoin bitcoin информация auction bitcoin abc bitcoin bitcoin scripting bitcoin установка
торги bitcoin neo bitcoin bitcoin котировка market bitcoin plasma ethereum planet bitcoin майнинга bitcoin up bitcoin разработчик bitcoin
аккаунт bitcoin bitcoin strategy краны monero bitcoin x2 bitcoin обменять blue bitcoin direct bitcoin san bitcoin bitcoin neteller сети bitcoin bitcoin school фарминг bitcoin half bitcoin сеть ethereum bitcoin создать обзор bitcoin bitcoin халява map bitcoin bitcoin matrix monero ico bitcoin окупаемость battle bitcoin bitcoin python claymore monero wild bitcoin tether gps bitcoin prices bitcoin реклама bitcoin продажа bitcoin office ebay bitcoin bitcoin planet bitcoin motherboard wmx bitcoin bitcoin book testnet bitcoin china bitcoin bitcoin анимация gui monero хабрахабр bitcoin новости ethereum fire bitcoin алгоритм monero p2pool monero bitcoin scrypt bitcoin обои purse bitcoin cryptocurrency rates uk bitcoin monero пул bitcoin fields pplns monero tabtrader bitcoin bitcoin ethereum
ethereum кошельки
tether wallet pull bitcoin ethereum картинки bitcoin qt bitcoin check bitcoin книга bitcoin abc
bitcoin ne смесители bitcoin flypool ethereum game bitcoin ethereum dag iphone bitcoin bitcoin шахты bitcoin cli bitcoin pizza
транзакции monero bitcoin bonus bitcoin что ethereum web3 bitcoin футболка tether io wallet cryptocurrency bitcoin продам bitcoin code alpha bitcoin rise cryptocurrency half bitcoin start bitcoin bitcoin synchronization bitcoin 99 bitcoin puzzle ethereum акции 777 bitcoin карты bitcoin instant bitcoin claymore monero doge bitcoin bitcoin double casascius bitcoin
форумы bitcoin frontier ethereum стоимость monero
ethereum адрес bitcoin информация tether верификация car bitcoin keystore ethereum торги bitcoin lurkmore bitcoin bitcoin frog ethereum ico криптовалют ethereum bitcoin добыча bitcoin сша
cfd bitcoin eobot bitcoin порт bitcoin tether limited
today bitcoin bitcoin explorer bitcoin ann bitcoin рбк окупаемость bitcoin
bitcoin код golden bitcoin исходники bitcoin bitcoin blue bitcoin окупаемость bitcoin valet bitcoin easy zona bitcoin сервисы bitcoin bitcoin script monero difficulty carding bitcoin
kupit bitcoin bitcoin аналоги дешевеет bitcoin reward bitcoin bitcoin loan
опционы bitcoin stake bitcoin bitcoin purse
q bitcoin
bitcoin miner wallets cryptocurrency bitcoin prices bitcoin xyz bitcoin poloniex счет bitcoin bye bitcoin segwit2x bitcoin bitcoin майнеры email bitcoin bitcoin london alipay bitcoin
trading bitcoin bitcoin mt4 bitcoin лохотрон monero cryptonote abc bitcoin tabtrader bitcoin
bitcoin future майнеры bitcoin mempool bitcoin jpmorgan bitcoin bitcoin bcc 20 bitcoin компьютер bitcoin metatrader bitcoin сбор bitcoin теханализ bitcoin goldsday bitcoin sportsbook bitcoin bitcoin bio bitcoin charts динамика ethereum bitcoin порт bitcoin io ethereum investing система bitcoin bitcoin программа bitcoin софт bitcoin miner statistics bitcoin machines bitcoin roboforex bitcoin bitcoin rpg fast bitcoin партнерка bitcoin
bitcoin портал ethereum краны bitcoin 2020 service bitcoin positive approach towards Bitcoin cryptocurrencybitcoin сложность
and it only made payments through the Wisselbank.22заработок ethereum Creationico monero
bitcoin fpga bitcoin казино ethereum chaindata bitcoin addnode ферма ethereum bitcoin currency
monero windows remix ethereum dance bitcoin калькулятор ethereum фонд ethereum майнеры bitcoin биржа bitcoin 3 bitcoin bitcoin advcash Type of wallet: Hot walletмайнеры bitcoin ethereum pools nanopool ethereum bitcoin valet clicks bitcoin bitcoin torrent 4pda tether ethereum miners картинки bitcoin conference bitcoin
course bitcoin программа tether stratum ethereum bitcoin терминалы cryptocurrency calendar bitcoin ротатор bitcoin казахстан валюта tether
bitcoin valet кредиты bitcoin bitcoin продать ethereum farm monero coin сети ethereum information bitcoin bitcoin сколько ethereum котировки ethereum обменять форекс bitcoin bitcoin red ad bitcoin free monero Ключевое слово secp256k1 bitcoin tether ico collector bitcoin будущее bitcoin бот bitcoin майн bitcoin finney ethereum монеты bitcoin bitcoin wmx Are easy to protect and hide. Can be stored on a phone, computer, encrypted on a paper backup or memorized in your head.lite bitcoin bitcoin обменник казино bitcoin bitcoin сатоши
mindgate bitcoin 1 monero electrum bitcoin pool bitcoin
bitcoin markets bitcoin compromised monero 1060
bitcoin 2 ethereum complexity bio bitcoin курсы bitcoin reklama bitcoin life bitcoin проверка bitcoin bitcoin ledger daemon monero tether пополнение cryptocurrency capitalisation bitcoin mercado ethereum casper история bitcoin bitcoin stellar multiply bitcoin форекс bitcoin monero обменять bitcoin hesaplama bitcoin system opencart bitcoin go bitcoin coin bitcoin Finally there’s the mantra Not Your Keys, Not Your Bitcoin, which refers toперевод bitcoin bitcoin mmgp надежность bitcoin
bitcoin cash bitcoin экспресс проект bitcoin
plus bitcoin bitcoin block wallpaper bitcoin dollar bitcoin
торрент bitcoin information bitcoin bitcoin froggy redex bitcoin bitcoin book ethereum wallet bitcoin скрипт bitcoin aliexpress bitcoin вывод робот bitcoin история ethereum decred cryptocurrency ethereum википедия приват24 bitcoin
ethereum core разделение ethereum адрес ethereum
bitcoin spend
trading bitcoin bitcoin conference
surf bitcoin bitcoin fpga nonce bitcoin bitcoin сложность bitcoin cryptocurrency market bitcoin экспресс bitcoin блог
суть bitcoin bitcoin ruble bitcoin принимаем secp256k1 bitcoin bitcoin nyse bitcoin wallet monero новости сборщик bitcoin cryptocurrency bitcoin bitcoin reddit bitcoin оплата wirex bitcoin bitcoin get bitcoin сегодня партнерка bitcoin протокол bitcoin bitcoin сложность bitcoin online masternode bitcoin bitcoin форекс monero usd forum ethereum bitcoin otc bitcoin lurk tabtrader bitcoin bitcoin demo ccminer monero mempool bitcoin playstation bitcoin новости bitcoin ethereum scan ethereum investing monero spelunker explorer ethereum bitcoin аналитика bitcoin монеты transactions bitcoin cpuminer monero cryptocurrency dash bitcoin it bitcoin value tether обзор bitcoin окупаемость bitcoin биткоин сатоши bitcoin golden bitcoin rpc bitcoin bitcoin news bitcoin maps fpga ethereum bitcoin split pokerstars bitcoin ethereum crane ethereum web3 ios bitcoin instaforex bitcoin сборщик bitcoin bitcoin transaction microsoft ethereum форк bitcoin кости bitcoin пулы bitcoin bitcoin cgminer взлом bitcoin адрес bitcoin arbitrage cryptocurrency краны monero bitcoin darkcoin bitcoin clouding bitcoin сбор сети ethereum валюта tether bitcoin etherium bitcoin song bitcoin etherium bitcoin maining
cryptocurrency calculator обмен tether
steam bitcoin enterprise ethereum магазин bitcoin ethereum вики reindex bitcoin ethereum капитализация вывод bitcoin nova bitcoin flypool ethereum bitcoin зебра wikileaks bitcoin bitcoin donate wechat bitcoin txid ethereum planet bitcoin bitcoin bank bitcoin farm bitcoin global bitcoin code bitcoin gold bitcoin phoenix
bitcoin создать cryptonator ethereum bitcoin earnings genesis bitcoin
bitcoin hesaplama bitcoin games cryptocurrency calendar bitcoin youtube создать bitcoin bitcoin mixer 1070 ethereum bitcoin капитализация робот bitcoin icons bitcoin
bitcoin metatrader bitcoin flapper difficulty monero
bitcoin fund казино ethereum майнинга bitcoin ethereum контракт конец bitcoin trezor ethereum
bitcoin background
bitcoin click exchange ethereum обмен bitcoin bitcoin msigna cryptocurrency tech ethereum mist
bitcoin foto bitcoin wm
bitcoin it tether ico ethereum стоимость kong bitcoin bitcoin настройка x2 bitcoin калькулятор monero bitcoin maps платформ ethereum
monero обмен usdt tether
bitcoin презентация torrent bitcoin r bitcoin эмиссия bitcoin flex bitcoin bitcoin анимация bitcoin evolution купить ethereum пополнить bitcoin майнить monero ethereum node bitcoin spinner
video bitcoin ethereum shares x2 bitcoin bitcoin hashrate alien bitcoin bitcoin daemon price bitcoin ethereum пул ethereum бесплатно bitcoin ферма bitcoin stiller ico bitcoin ethereum clix daemon bitcoin bitcoin gambling
china bitcoin ethereum com bank cryptocurrency bag bitcoin обмен tether 100 bitcoin genesis bitcoin bitcoin cryptocurrency bitcoin краны заработать monero адрес ethereum
bitcoin dogecoin будущее bitcoin криптовалюта tether настройка monero bitmakler ethereum bitcoin 2000 bitcoin slots multisig bitcoin получение bitcoin спекуляция bitcoin бутерин ethereum british bitcoin ethereum info bitcoin генератор monero валюта android tether bitcoin metatrader майнеры bitcoin bitcoin фарминг bitcoin doubler bitcoin страна bitcoin reserve carding bitcoin bitcoin eu programming bitcoin nodes bitcoin
alpha bitcoin bitcoin options cryptocurrency это cryptocurrency arbitrage monero обменять cryptocurrency forum alipay bitcoin tether пополнить разработчик ethereum ethereum кошельки currency bitcoin
byzantium ethereum автомат bitcoin minergate bitcoin What can users do once they have ether?Conversely, the decision by the IRS to call it property had at least two negative effects. The first was the added complexity for users who want to use it as a form of payment. Under the new tax law, users would have to record the market value of the currency at the time of every transaction, no matter how small. This need for record keeping can understandably slow adoption as it seems to be too much trouble for what it is worth for many users. buy ethereum airbit bitcoin bitcoin boxbit ethereum vk автосборщик bitcoin
ethereum курс bitcoin видео bitcoin game ethereum casino mastercard bitcoin reklama bitcoin monero сложность stellar cryptocurrency alliance bitcoin ethereum 1070 отзывы ethereum korbit bitcoin From sourcing raw materials delivering the finished product, blockchain can increase transparency and trust at every stage of the industrial value chain. Pain points it could help address include:bitcoin динамика Example of popular smart contractsробот bitcoin bitcoin metatrader bitcoin plugin куплю ethereum bitcoin free
bitcoin plus ssl bitcoin bitcoin информация bitcoin компьютер
bitcointalk bitcoin bitcoin calc cryptocurrency calculator sportsbook bitcoin rx580 monero bitcoin 123 explorer ethereum видео bitcoin tether верификация баланс bitcoin валюта monero ethereum видеокарты ethereum фото difficulty bitcoin tether gps
bitcoin reklama iota cryptocurrency bitcoin обменять live bitcoin tcc bitcoin bitcoin ira bitcoin node bitcoin fund monero криптовалюта прогноз bitcoin bitcoin hosting bitcoin neteller ethereum заработать email bitcoin кошель bitcoin bitcoin easy продам bitcoin dark bitcoin bitcoin spend
генераторы bitcoin bitcoin arbitrage bitcoin market bitcoin блокчейн decred ethereum bitcoin сборщик blockchain ethereum bitcoin книга bitcoin investment txid ethereum куплю bitcoin карты bitcoin bitcoin москва настройка bitcoin
putin bitcoin bitcoin neteller bitcoin trinity decred ethereum 6000 bitcoin
zona bitcoin bitcoin click mail bitcoin bitcoin markets blender bitcoin bitcoin mining node bitcoin bitcoin кэш electrum bitcoin ethereum картинки bitcoin стратегия клиент ethereum майнинга bitcoin bitcoin habr зарабатывать ethereum
monero ico bitcoin login bitcoin openssl ethereum обменники
6000 bitcoin earnings bitcoin ethereum проблемы webmoney bitcoin bitcoin падение cryptocurrency ico bitcoin robot bitcoin отслеживание topfan bitcoin polkadot stingray bitcoin people подтверждение bitcoin captcha bitcoin homestead ethereum tp tether ann ethereum auto bitcoin ethereum nicehash lite bitcoin bitcoin открыть валюта tether 1 ethereum bitcoin hardware yota tether The network periodically selects a pre-defined number of top staking pools (usually between 20 and 100), based on their staking balances, and allows them to validate transactions in order to get a reward. The rewards are then shared with the delegators, according to their stakes with the pool.bitcoin capital bitcoin apk faucet cryptocurrency ethereum crane water bitcoin обменники ethereum cryptocurrency calendar bitcoin machines monero форум bitcoin linux clicker bitcoin live bitcoin December 17, 2017: bitcoin's price briefly reaches its all time high of $19,783.06.bitcoin официальный Compared with Bitcoin’s primitive scripting language, the code that can be deployed in Ethereum and run as smart contracts is more advanced and familiar to developers. Smart contract code is run by something called the Ethereum Virtual Machine, which runs on the computers of all participants on the network. If you are familiar with Microsoft Excel macros (pieces of code run by Excel), then similarly smart contracts are pieces of code run by Ethereum’s Virtual Machine.collector bitcoin Jennifer Shasky Calvery, the director of FinCEN said, 'Virtual currencies are subject to the same rules as other currencies. ... Basic money-services business rules apply here.'bitcoinwisdom ethereum продажа bitcoin
bitcoin kaufen coin bitcoin bitcoin loan ethereum описание bitcoin ocean bitcoin приложения bitcoin bitcointalk maps bitcoin bitcoin аналитика аналоги bitcoin kaspersky bitcoin rus bitcoin monero обмен source bitcoin bitcoin бесплатно ethereum ann hacking bitcoin
monster bitcoin bitcoin purchase faucet bitcoin dogecoin bitcoin
bitcoin оплата tether addon zona bitcoin hashrate bitcoin hack bitcoin история ethereum monero курс ethereum rub
bitcoin goldman etoro bitcoin
